|
| Year | League | Record | Finish | Stadium | Attendance | Attend/G | Attend Rank |
| 2006 | AL East | 97-65 | DIV,1 | Yankee Stadium | 4,200,518 | 51,858 | 1st out of 14 |
| 2005 | AL East | 95-67 | DIV,1 | Yankee Stadium | 4,090,696 | 50,502 | 1st out of 14 |
| 2004 | AL East | 101-61 | DIV,1 | Yankee Stadium | 3,775,292 | 46,609 | 1st out of 14 |
| 2003 | AL East | 101-61 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 3,465,600 | 42,263 | 1st out of 14 |
| 2002 | AL East | 103-58 | DIV,1 | Yankee Stadium | 3,465,807 | 43,323 | 2nd out of 14 |
| 2001 | AL East | 95-65 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 3,264,907 | 40,811 | 2nd out of 14 |
| 2000 | AL East | 87-74 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 3,055,435 | 38,193 | 3rd out of 14 |
| 1999 | AL East | 98-64 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 3,292,736 | 40,651 | 3rd out of 14 |
| 1998 | AL East | 114-48 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 2,955,193 | 36,484 | 3rd out of 14 |
| 1997 | AL East | 96-66 | WC,2 | Yankee Stadium | 2,580,325 | 32,254 | 5th out of 14 |
| 1996 | AL East | 92-70 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 2,250,877 | 28,136 | 7th out of 14 |
| 1995 | AL East | 79-65 | WC,2 | Yankee Stadium | 1,705,263 | 23,360 | 7th out of 14 |
| 1994 | AL East | 70-43 | 1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,675,556 | 29,396 | 6th out of 14 |
| 1993 | AL East | 88-74 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 2,416,942 | 29,839 | 5th out of 14 |
| 1992 | AL East | 76-86 | 4 | Yankee Stadium | 1,748,737 | 21,589 | 11th out of 14 |
| 1991 | AL East | 71-91 | 5 | Yankee Stadium | 1,863,733 | 23,009 | 11th out of 14 |
| 1990 | AL East | 67-95 | 7 | Yankee Stadium | 2,006,436 | 24,771 | 9th out of 14 |
| 1989 | AL East | 74-87 | 5 | Yankee Stadium | 2,170,485 | 26,796 | 8th out of 14 |
| 1988 | AL East | 85-76 | 5 | Yankee Stadium | 2,633,701 | 32,921 | 2nd out of 14 |
| 1987 | AL East | 89-73 | 4 | Yankee Stadium | 2,427,672 | 29,971 | 3rd out of 14 |
| 1986 | AL East | 90-72 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 2,268,030 | 28,350 | 4th out of 14 |
| 1985 | AL East | 97-64 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 2,214,587 | 27,682 | 4th out of 14 |
| 1984 | AL East | 87-75 | 3 | Yankee Stadium | 1,821,815 | 22,492 | 6th out of 14 |
| 1983 | AL East | 91-71 | 3 | Yankee Stadium | 2,257,976 | 27,876 | 3rd out of 14 |
| 1982 | AL East | 79-83 | 5 | Yankee Stadium | 2,041,219 | 25,200 | 3rd out of 14 |
| 1981 | AL East | 59-48 | AL, | Yankee Stadium | 1,614,353 | 31,654 | 1st out of 14 |
| 1980 | AL East | 103-59 | DIV,1 | Yankee Stadium | 2,627,417 | 32,437 | 1st out of 14 |
| 1979 | AL East | 89-71 | 4 | Yankee Stadium | 2,537,765 | 31,330 | 1st out of 14 |
| 1978 | AL East | 100-63 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 2,335,871 | 28,838 | 1st out of 14 |
| 1977 | AL East | 100-62 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 2,103,092 | 25,964 | 1st out of 14 |
| 1976 | AL East | 97-62 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 2,012,434 | 25,155 | 1st out of 12 |
| 1975 | AL East | 83-77 | 3 | Shea Stadium | 1,288,048 | 16,513 | 2nd out of 12 |
| 1974 | AL East | 89-73 | 2 | Shea Stadium | 1,273,075 | 15,717 | 2nd out of 12 |
| 1973 | AL East | 80-82 | 4 | Yankee Stadium | 1,262,103 | 15,582 | 5th out of 12 |
| 1972 | AL East | 79-76 | 4 | Yankee Stadium | 966,328 | 12,550 | 4th out of 12 |
| 1971 | AL East | 82-80 | 4 | Yankee Stadium | 1,070,771 | 13,219 | 4th out of 12 |
| 1970 | AL East | 93-69 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 1,136,879 | 14,036 | 4th out of 12 |
| 1969 | AL East | 80-81 | 5 | Yankee Stadium | 1,067,996 | 13,350 | 4th out of 12 |
| 1968 | American Lg | 83-79 | 5 | Yankee Stadium | 1,185,666 | 14,459 | 3rd out of 10 |
| 1967 | American Lg | 72-90 | 9 | Yankee Stadium | 1,259,514 | 15,360 | 5th out of 10 |
| 1966 | American Lg | 70-89 | 10 | Yankee Stadium | 1,124,648 | 13,715 | 5th out of 10 |
| 1965 | American Lg | 77-85 | 6 | Yankee Stadium | 1,213,552 | 14,621 | 2nd out of 10 |
| 1964 | American Lg | 99-63 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,305,638 | 16,119 | 1st out of 10 |
| 1963 | American Lg | 104-57 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,308,920 | 16,362 | 2nd out of 10 |
| 1962 | American Lg | 96-66 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,493,574 | 18,670 | 1st out of 10 |
| 1961 | American Lg | 109-53 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,747,725 | 21,577 | 1st out of 10 |
| 1960 | American Lg | 97-57 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,627,349 | 21,134 | 2nd out of 8 |
| 1959 | American Lg | 79-75 | 3 | Yankee Stadium | 1,552,030 | 20,156 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1958 | American Lg | 92-62 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,428,438 | 18,313 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1957 | American Lg | 98-56 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,497,134 | 19,443 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1956 | American Lg | 97-57 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,491,784 | 19,374 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1955 | American Lg | 96-58 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,490,138 | 19,352 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1954 | American Lg | 103-51 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 1,475,171 | 18,912 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1953 | American Lg | 99-52 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,537,811 | 19,972 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1952 | American Lg | 95-59 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,629,665 | 21,164 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1951 | American Lg | 98-56 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,950,107 | 25,001 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1950 | American Lg | 98-56 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 2,081,380 | 27,031 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1949 | American Lg | 97-57 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 2,283,676 | 29,278 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1948 | American Lg | 94-60 | 3 | Yankee Stadium | 2,373,901 | 30,830 | 2nd out of 8 |
| 1947 | American Lg | 97-57 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 2,178,937 | 28,298 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1946 | American Lg | 87-67 | 3 | Yankee Stadium | 2,265,512 | 29,422 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1945 | American Lg | 81-71 | 4 | Yankee Stadium | 881,845 | 11,603 | 2nd out of 8 |
| 1944 | American Lg | 83-71 | 3 | Yankee Stadium | 789,995 | 10,128 | 2nd out of 8 |
| 1943 | American Lg | 98-56 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 618,330 | 8,030 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1942 | American Lg | 103-51 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 922,011 | 11,974 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1941 | American Lg | 101-53 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 964,722 | 12,368 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1940 | American Lg | 88-66 | 3 | Yankee Stadium | 988,975 | 13,013 | 2nd out of 8 |
| 1939 | American Lg | 106-45 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 859,785 | 11,166 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1938 | American Lg | 99-53 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 970,916 | 12,290 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1937 | American Lg | 102-52 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 998,148 | 12,635 | 2nd out of 8 |
| 1936 | American Lg | 102-51 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 976,913 | 12,687 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1935 | American Lg | 89-60 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 657,508 | 8,885 | 2nd out of 8 |
| 1934 | American Lg | 94-60 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 854,682 | 11,100 | 2nd out of 8 |
| 1933 | American Lg | 91-59 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 728,014 | 9,707 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1932 | American Lg | 107-47 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 962,320 | 12,498 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1931 | American Lg | 94-59 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 912,437 | 11,850 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1930 | American Lg | 86-68 | 3 | Yankee Stadium | 1,169,230 | 15,385 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1929 | American Lg | 88-66 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 960,148 | 12,469 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1928 | American Lg | 101-53 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,072,132 | 13,924 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1927 | American Lg | 110-44 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,164,015 | 15,117 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1926 | American Lg | 91-63 | AL,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,027,675 | 13,702 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1925 | American Lg | 69-85 | 7 | Yankee Stadium | 697,267 | 8,826 | 5th out of 8 |
| 1924 | American Lg | 89-63 | 2 | Yankee Stadium | 1,053,533 | 13,507 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1923 | American Lg | 98-54 | WS,1 | Yankee Stadium | 1,007,066 | 13,251 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1922 | American Lg | 94-60 | AL,1 | Polo Grounds | 1,026,134 | 13,326 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1921 | American Lg | 98-55 | AL,1 | Polo Grounds | 1,230,696 | 15,778 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1920 | American Lg | 95-59 | 3 | Polo Grounds | 1,289,422 | 16,746 | 1st out of 8 |
| 1919 | American Lg | 80-59 | 3 | Polo Grounds | 619,164 | 8,482 | 3rd out of 8 |
| 1918 | American Lg | 60-63 | 4 | Polo Grounds | 282,047 | 4,210 | 2nd out of 8 |
| 1917 | American Lg | 71-82 | 6 | Polo Grounds | 330,294 | 4,404 | 5th out of 8 |
| 1916 | American Lg | 80-74 | 4 | Polo Grounds | 469,211 | 5,939 | 5th out of 8 |